Showing posts with label Municipal Elections Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Municipal Elections Act. Show all posts

Monday, September 13, 2010

Pot calling the kettle black

Mayoral candidate Jim Watson does a wonderful job selling his “integrity plan” and dissing opponent Larry O’Brien. In the process he appears to have stolen some of mayoral candidate Clive Doucet’s ideas, no sole-sourcing for example. However, he does not plan on revisiting the Lansdowne Park sole-source decision.


Unfortunately, Watson’s plan also overlooks some of his own transgressions; in particular, candidates taking developers’ donations. He could have taken action on this issue in his previous role as municipalities minister in the Ontario government, but didn’t. Larry O’Brien talks about “releasing corporate donations” but Clive Doucet didn’t need a “policy” to know it is wrong to take donations from developers.

Clive Doucet is now the only leading mayoral candidate that does not take donations from developers, and this has been a key plank of his campaign from the beginning.

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Raising campaign funds without corporate/union donations

Some municipal election campaign fundraisers still seem to think it is necessary to go to corporate donors in order to raise the funds needed to run an effective campaign for their candidate. This is really not the case if private donors take advantage of the city’s refund policy. People donating modest amounts to municipal election campaigns can receive a substantial refund from the city making campaign donations affordable; even for people of modest means.

First of all, it is important to verify that the candidate(s) whose campaigns one wishes to support are registered in the Contribution rebate program. Details on how to apply for a rebate are available on the City of Ottawa web site at: http://www.ottawa.ca/city_hall/elections/contribution_rebate/index_en.html. Here is a summary:

If you are issued a receipt entitled "Receipt - Candidate Campaign Contribution - Rebate Program" for the 2010 Municipal Election then you may apply for a contribution rebate provided:

* the contribution was monetary and not goods or services;
* the contribution was $50 or more;
* the contribution was made to a candidate participating in the rebate program; and
* the contribution came from you as an individual and not through a business, corporation or trade union.

A rebate is only payable if the candidate to whom you have made a contribution has complied with all of the provisions of By-law 2005-505. As part of these provisions, a candidate must first register to participate in the contribution rebate program with the City Clerk by the end of nomination day.

A minimum contribution of $50.00 is required to be eligible for a rebate. An individual who -makes contributions to more than one candidate may apply for a rebate in respect of each contribution (minimum contribution of $50.00 per candidate) but is not entitled to receive total rebates exceeding the maximum rebate of $187.50.

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Developers’ influence on the city

In a letter to the Ottawa Citizen (Developers’ influence on the city a big deal, July 17, 2010) Councillor Clive Doucet illustrates how developers’ contributions to municipal election campaigns become a “big deal.” A large majority of Councillors accepted donation from corporate sources or from people with corporate interests in the 2006 municipal election. Here are two examples:

Some 80% of Councillor Doug Thompson’s campaign donations came from corporate sources, mostly from the construction and development sectors.

Over 62% of Councillor Peter Hume’s campaign donations came from individual owners, executives or senior managers of businesses in the construction and development sectors. There were no direct contributions from corporations however.

It is apparent that many candidates do not consider the ethical dilemma they place themselves in by accepting donations from corporations as well as from individuals whose businesses might later benefit from decisions and action taken by city council. This has got to change.

Wednesday, July 7, 2010

The mayoralty race has suddenly become interesting

Councillor Clive Doucet’s decision to enter the mayoralty campaign has come as a surprise to everyone. Interesting times are looming ahead for all the mayoral candidates. There are now four high profile candidates for mayor; three of them are currently members of council.

I am encouraged by Mr. Doucet’s opening statements “I’m not running to be the developer’s go-to-guy and I will not run the city behind closed doors.” Doucet also indicates that his campaign will be financed by “small donations from ordinary people.”

These are words that all candidates for mayor and city council need to pay attention to. I have long opposed election campaign funding by corporate and union donors as well as by owners, executives and senior staff of corporations. Regrettably, there is only a small group of existing councillors that do not accept donations from these sources. It’s time for this issue to be cleared up once and for all. No matter how much councillors take offence and protest that their votes cannot be bought when challenged on this issue, the perception will always be there. We must remove the temptation.

Whatever one feels about Councillor Doucet’s views, it cannot be denied that he is one of the most honest and sincere members of council. Watch and learn!

Monday, December 14, 2009

Nothing wrong with banning corporate and union donations

I don’t understand the concern that Jim Watson or anyone else has about a proposed ban on municipal (and provincial) election campaign donations (Cullen, Watson conflict over ban, Lee Greenberg, Ottawa Citizen, September 14, 2009). The article indicates that business owners have already found a way around corporate donations by making individual donations instead. In Ottawa I have also noted that other company executives and senior managers also make substantial campaign donations.

This makes it a little more difficult to track down links between companies and donors, but it can be done; Google is pretty helpful! I recall that Ottawa City Council passed a motion this year requiring candidates to provide a list of their campaign donors within 4 weeks of the election date. Presumably, they will be required to update this list at the end of the campaign as well, so that citizens can vote with full knowledge of candidates’ campaign donations? I hope I have this right?

In the article Robert MacDermid notes “…The 2003 Liberal campaign platform dedicates an entire section to ‘reducing the influence of money in politics’” MacDermid also says “…the McGuinty Liberals have become dependent on corporate donations and are unlikely to ban them in Ottawa and elsewhere. 'They would look incredibly hypocritical if they banned it at the municipal level and didn’t ban it themselves’…”

The only immediate solution is for City council to take steps itself as Toronto City Council has already done.

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Toronto city councillors agree to ban campaign donations from corporations and unions

According to an article in today’s Toronto Star, city councillors have decided they will no longer accept campaign donations from corporations or unions, putting pressure on the provincial government to ban the practice in all municipalities across Ontario (City clamps down on election donors, Paul Mulroney and Vanessa Lu, Toronto Star, Dec 3, 2009).

The vote was passed 29 – 12 following a day-long debate. Council also voted 27-13 to study the feasibility of providing some city funding for campaigns. Robert MacDermid a York University professor and advocate for election reform told reporters. "...It's the first step to get rid of this kind of influence. It's about removing the unfairness and discrimination that's involved in the system…"

Some Toronto councillors now want to lobby Ontario Municipal Affairs Minister Jim Watson to push for a similar ban across the province, by changing the Municipal Elections Act.

This is a step in the right direction. One wonders whether Ottawa City councillors have the ethical foresight to follow Toronto’s lead here.

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Corporate donations to municipal election campaigns

The issue of corporate donations to candidates campaigning for office at municipal and provincial levels has been a concern of mine for a long time. At the federal level Elections Canada took steps to eliminate corporate donation some time ago. Why are the two lower levels of government not introducing similar legislation?

If the province introduced income tax credits at the municipal level, similar to those that already exist at federal and provincial levels, more people would consider donating to municipal candidates’ campaigns. This in turn might result in renewed levels of interest in municipal elections and help increase the number of voters who turn out.

It was disappointing, though not surprising, to learn that Ottawa City councillors have turned down yet another opportunity to speak to the provincial government on this issue (Bid to ban corporate, union donations fails, Patrick Dare, Ottawa Citizen, November 24, 2009). A motion by Councillor Alex Cullen to ask the province to prohibit such donations was defeated by a vote of 4-6 by the audit, budget and finance committee.

Dare’s article notes that only five councillors out of the 24 on council do not accept corporate donation and union donations. However, at least one member of this group of five receives a substantial amount of donations to his campaign from individual owners, executives and senior staff of corporations, primarily developers. Interestingly, this individual voted in favor of Cullen’s motion.

New municipal election rules that are being considered by the province will put a limit on the maximum value of contributions that any individual, corporation or other organization can make. But this does not prevent a large number of individuals with ties to a particular corporation or organization from donating. This defeats the intent of the proposed legislation.

It’s time for this issue to be cleared up once and for all. No matter how much councillors take offence and protest that their votes cannot be bought when challenged on this issue, the perception will always be there. We just need to remove the temptation.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Municipal Election Campaign Donations

Concern over municipal election campaign donations from corporations and unions appears to be building (Councillor calls for corporate donations ban, CBC Ottawa web site, November 2, 2009). Whether or not proposed changes to the Province of Ontario’s Municipal election Act are passed, remains to be seen. But ethical dilemmas will persist for Councillors who receive contributions from prominent individuals who’s firms or employers could benefit from later decisions and actions taken by city council.

The phrase “my vote cannot be bought” has been heard quite often recently, particularly in connection with OSCG’s Lansdowne Live proposal. Nonetheless there were significant donations from corporations and prominent individuals to elected Councillor’s campaigns in 2006 (http://communities.canada.com/ottawacitizen, Political donations and Lansdowne Live, David Reveley, September 30, 2009).

Reveley concludes he is comfortable “...that none of the winning candidates owes his or her seat on council to money from the Lansdowne Live proponents. Any connection is sure to be more subtle….” However, the article also notes that “…When a candidate got money from these guys, chances are he or she also got money from other developers and builders and consultants, for instance, who might get pieces of Lansdowne work if Lansdowne Live goes ahead…”

While the total amount of contributions is small in relative terms, it is difficult to believe that such contributions do not influence collective decision making in some way. Only nine elected Councillors did not accept donations from OSEG members in 2006.

I have posted previously on the issue of corporate campaign contributions. My concerns will not be satisfied by proposed amendments to the Act now being considered by the Province. It is disturbing that provincial law continues to allow contributions of this nature when strict measures to limit implications of inappropriate election contributions have been enacted at the federal level.

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Urgent need to update the Municipal Elections Act

Longstanding concerns over allowable municipal election campaign contributions from within the development industry are the focus of an article in today’s Toronto Star (Municipal Elections Act need urgent update to curb abuses, Robert MacDermid, The Star, October 14, 2009). The article addresses the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) and surrounding municipalities but the points that arise are applicable elsewhere in the province, including the City of Ottawa.

I quote fairly extensively from the article in the following paragraphs in order to make my point. In recent election campaigns a large percentage of City of Ottawa Councillors accepted donations from developers and from individual owners, executives and senior employees within the development industry. The parallels here with the situation in the GTA are very clear.

Quoting from the article:

“The City of Toronto auditor's report showed that 29 of 45 elected members of council violated the campaign finance reporting laws. And the Star's long-running campaign has pointed out abuses in municipal elections…There is evidence of the pervasive influence of the development industry in electing municipal council members. In Brampton, Mississauga, Oshawa, Pickering, Richmond Hill and probably Vaughan more than 50 per cent of the money for council members' 2006 campaigns came from the development industry. And 28 of 132 winners in 10 inner-GTA municipalities gathered more than 66 per cent of their campaign cash from the development industry.”

Several Ottawa City Councillors have noted that the maximum allowable campaign contribution limit ($750) is too low to possibly influence a Councillor’s vote were they prepared to be bought. However, as the article notes “ it will get access to a councillor and, when coordinated with other contributions, it ensures that some, or even all, council members are favourable to development proposals – no matter how dysfunctional from an urban planning perspective.”

MacDermid states that:

“You would think that the parade of municipal representatives to the courts for violations of campaign finance law would have spurred Municipal affairs Minister Jim Watson yo reform the Municipal elections Act

“...The minister's reform package, if it is passed in time for the start of elections in January, is likely to be piecemeal and allow little or no time for public hearings.

“It is expected that he will raise the expenditure limits. This is something that incumbents want because it raises the bar for challengers – but the legislation should encourage challenges. Incumbents already have an advantage over challengers. Moreover, 75 per cent of 674 candidates in 10 GTA municipalities had total expenditures in 2006 that did not surpass two-thirds of current limits, so there is no need to raise them.

“More fundamental reforms are needed to end the embrace of the development industry. The stakes are high. Municipal councils create profits for developers by rezoning and servicing land and current residents subsidize new development because developments charges are too low. Campaign contributions from corporations and unions should be banned from municipal politics, as they are in federal politics and Quebec and Manitoba provincial politics.

“It is not just that corporate money is prevalent but as long as big companies have the right to make campaign contributions, it allows the owners to give in their own name and then direct money from one or more companies as well.

“…These are some other reforms that are essential to make municipal elections open and transparent.

- “The minister should change the law to prevent winning candidates carrying forward surpluses that give them a head start over challengers at future elections.
- “He should require that municipalities form compliance audit committees so that citizen complaints about campaigns go to an independent tribunal rather than council members who, all too frequently, have declined to investigate their colleagues.
- “He should limit the number of contributions someone can make to five. For example, the Greater Toronto Sewer and Water main Contractors' Association gave to 95 candidates (72 of them elected) in 10 municipalities in 2006.
- “And he needs to close the most egregious of loopholes, allowing companies to pay employees while they work on campaigns without the expense being considered a contribution from the employer.

“All these reforms are badly needed to restore credibility to the municipal democratic election process.

“The McGuinty government was elected on the promise of democratic reforms. There is no better place to show that commitment than by enacting meaningful changes to the Municipal Elections Act before the starting bell for campaigns rings in January of 2010. The time is short and the need to restore legitimacy is great.”

People I have spoken within the City of Ottawa would like Minister Watson to go even further by allowing contributions only from voters.